External drive works on one computer but not another?
Your external hard drive works perfectly on one computer but does nothing on another. Perhaps it shows up on your old desktop but not your new laptop, works on your Mac but not a Windows PC, or appears in Device Manager on one machine and nowhere at all on the other. It is tempting to assume the drive is fine because “it works over there”. Often that is true and the cause is simple. Sometimes, though, a drive that only works on one computer is giving an early warning that it is starting to fail. Here is how to tell the difference without putting your files at risk.
Power: the most common reason
Portable 2.5-inch drives take all their power from the USB port. Some computers, particularly slim laptops, older USB 2.0 ports, front-panel ports on desktops and unpowered hubs or adapters, supply less current than others. A drive that is healthy but slightly power-hungry may spin up on a desktop’s rear port and fail to start on a thin laptop.
- Plug the drive straight into the computer, not into a hub, dock, keyboard or monitor port.
- On a desktop, use a port on the back, which connects directly to the motherboard.
- If your laptop only has USB-C, try a different adapter or a USB-C cable made for the drive. Cheap adapters are a frequent cause.
- Try a short, good-quality cable. The Micro-B USB 3.0 connectors on many portable drives wear and loosen over time.
If the drive spins up, clicks or beeps and then drops off on the weaker computer, that points to power or a drive that now needs more power than before because it is struggling mechanically.
Format: Mac and Windows read different file systems
A drive formatted on one type of computer may not be readable on another, even though it is perfectly healthy:
- APFS or Mac OS Extended (HFS+) drives formatted on a Mac are not readable by Windows as standard. Windows may show no drive letter, or offer to format the disk.
- NTFS drives formatted on Windows can be read on a Mac, but macOS will not write to them without extra software.
- exFAT works on both, which is why many drives are shipped that way, but it has no journal, so it is easily damaged if the drive is unplugged without ejecting.
If Windows asks you to format a drive that works on your Mac, click Cancel. Formatting would erase the file system that holds your files. Copy what you need using the computer that can read it.
Drive letters, drivers and security software
On Windows, a drive can be detected but not visible in File Explorer:
- Open Disk Management. If the drive is listed with a healthy partition but no letter, it may simply need a drive letter assigned. This is a safe change, but only make it if the partition is shown as healthy, and do not initialise or format anything.
- The drive may be trying to use a letter already taken by a mapped network drive or card reader on that PC.
- Drives protected with encryption, such as BitLocker or some manufacturer security software, need the password or recovery key on the second computer. Without it the drive can look empty or unreadable.
- Company laptops sometimes block USB storage by policy. That is a setting, not a drive fault, and your IT team can confirm it.
Signs the drive itself is the problem
Be more cautious if you notice any of these:
- The drive used to work on both computers and now only works on one.
- It is slow, freezes File Explorer or Finder, or disconnects during copies even on the computer where it “works”.
- It makes clicking, beeping or repeated spin-up sounds.
- It shows the wrong capacity, or appears and disappears.
- Windows reports errors such as a cyclic redundancy check or an I/O device error.
These suggest weak heads, bad sectors or a failing USB bridge board. In that case, use the computer where the drive still works to copy your most important files first, one folder at a time, and stop if the copy stalls or the drive disconnects. Do not run CHKDSK, repair utilities or recovery software, as heavy reading puts more strain on a failing drive.
What not to do
- Do not format or initialise the drive on the computer that cannot read it.
- Do not keep plugging it in and out in the hope that it starts working.
- Do not remove the drive from its case unless you know it is safe to do so. Some external drives have encryption built into the USB board, so the bare drive cannot be read without it.
Getting help
If the drive will no longer work on any computer, or copying your files keeps failing, leave it disconnected and ask for help. We recover data from all the major brands, including WD external hard drives and Seagate hard drives, and you can request a quote online.
Call Data Retrieval on 020 7064 4996 for a free assessment, with no obligation.
